| Protection/ Benefits | Stone Coated Steel Systems | Concrete Tile & Shake | Architectural Composition Shingle | Wood Shake |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lightweight** | 1.5 lbs/sq. ft Average roof 4,200 lbs |
9.5 lbs/sq. ft Average roof 36,000 lbs |
3-4 lbs/sq. ft Average roof 10,050 lbs |
3.5 lbs/sq. ft Average roof 10,500 lbs |
| Fire Protection | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent | Fair |
| Hail | Excellent | Good | Fair | Poor |
| Wind | 120 MPH Warranty | Fair* | Fair* | Poor |
| Weathering | Lifetime Warranty | Good | Fair | Poor |
| Ice / Snow | Excellent | Poor | Good | Fair |
| Re-sale value | Excellent | Excellent | Fair | Fair |
| Prestique High Definition Laminated Shingles, Shaded for Shake Look. | |
| Stone Coated 26 gauge steel roofing system shake & tile profiles | |
| 20 year 3-Tab, Oakridge | |
| Presidential Shake Presidential Tri-laminates |
|
| Sentinel, Grand Sequoia, Grand Canyon |